Satisfaction Guaranteed

Try Risk-Free with Our Satisfaction Guarantee

We stand behind the quality of these premium brands with our satisfaction guarantee. If your pet doesn't love it, simply bring your receipt and the product back to the store for a full store credit—no questions asked!

How It Works

  • Try It Risk-Free - Purchase any product from our satisfaction guaranteed brands
  • Let Your Pet Decide - Give your pet a chance to try the food or treat
  • Easy Returns - If your pet doesn't love it, bring your receipt and product to our store
  • Get Store Credit - Receive full store credit to try something else your pet will enjoy

Why We Offer This Guarantee

We know every pet has unique tastes and preferences. Our satisfaction guarantee takes the risk out of trying new premium foods and treats, so you can find exactly what your pet loves without worry. These brands are carefully selected for their quality, nutrition, and palatability—and we're confident your pet will agree!

Shop with confidence knowing we're here to help you find the perfect products for your furry friend.

Satisfaction Guaranteed
19 products
+4
Fussie Cat in Goat Milk Gravy Can - Wet Cat Food with Digestive Support Fussie Cat $225
NutriSource Grain Inclusive Dry Dog Food *Special Order Only* Sunburst Pet Supplies from $1800
Fussie Cat Gravy Pouches - Wet Cat Food 2.47oz **FINAL SALE** Fussie Cat $150
Fussie Cat Tuna in Aspic - Wet Cat Food Fussie Cat $225
Pure Vita Grain-Free Cat Dry Food PureVita from $2000
Fussie Cat Black Label in Gravy - Wet Cat Food 2.8oz Fussie Cat $225
Fussie Cat Puree in Goat Milk - Premium Cat Treats Fussie Cat $500
Fussie Cat - Gold Label Chicken in Gravy Wet Food for Cats 2.82oz **FINAL SALE** Fussie Cat $225
NutriSource Grain Free Dry Dog Food *Special Order Only* Nutrisource from $2500
NutriSource - Come-Pooch-A Bone Broth For Dogs *Special Order Only* Nutrisource $1000
NutriSource - Element Crispy Crispers Nutrisource $700
NutriSource Nutty Butter Bites - Peanut Butter Dog Treats Sunburst Pet Supplies $775
Fussie Cat - Tuna & Chicken Variety Pack (Single tubes) Rio Grande $125
Fussie Cat Market Fresh - Dry Food for Cats *Discontinued* Fussie Cat from $1800
Fussie Cat - Tuna with Aspic Variety Wet Food Pouches for Cats 2.47oz *Discontinued Fussie Cat $125
Nutrisource Kitten & Cat with Goat Milk Pate 5.5oz Sunburst Pet Supplies $250
Nutrisource Elements - Freeze Dried Raw Bites for Dogs Sunburst Pet Supplies from $850
NutriSource Kitten & Cat GF w/Goat Milk 4lb bag Sunburst Pet Supplies $2400
Sold Out
Nutrisource Element GF Cat Food 11lb - Classic Catch *Special Order Only* Sunburst Pet Supplies $6600
Recently viewed